My Nighttime Trick for Late-Night Cravings

Key Takeaways
- Fairlife shakes use ultra-filtered milk, offering high protein but still being a dairy product.
- For sensitive guts, a plant-based alternative like almond milk is often much gentler.
- Your late-night choice should support sleep, not stimulate digestion.
- Whole food options can be just as convenient with a little prep.
The clock strikes 10 PM. You're winding down, but a hollow feeling in your stomach starts to grow. It's not a full-on hunger pang, just a persistent whisper that says, 'snack time.' Reaching for the pantry feels like opening Pandora's box, risking a sugar spiral that disrupts your sleep and digestion.
This late-night window is a danger zone for anyone trying to manage their weight. Heavy meals sit like a stone, while sugary treats spike your blood sugar, leading to restless nights and morning cravings. You need something that satisfies the hunger without derailing your progress or upsetting your gut.
A protein shake seems like the easy answer. Fairlife's Core Power shakes are popular for their convenience and lactose-free milk protein. But are they the best choice for your gut and your goals? Let's look at what's really in that bottle and what your body might prefer in the quiet hours.
Sugar Analysis

Comparison of sugar content per serving (Lower is better).
The Redditor's Verdict
"What the community is actually saying..."
People appreciate the convenience and high protein count of Fairlife, noting it tastes good and helps with muscle recovery. However, many report digestive discomfort, even with the 'lactose-free' label. The taste can be too sweet for some, and the price point is a frequent complaint. Plant-based alternatives are often praised for being easier on the stomach.

Almond milk
The best overall choice based on taste, ingredients, and value.
In-Depth Reviews
Almond milk
Scanning this label feels reassuringly simple. With just 2g of sugar per 100ml, it's a very light touch of sweetness, letting the almond notes come through without being sugary. The texture is likely quite thin and clean, making it a versatile pour for your morning coffee or cereal without overpowering the other flavors. It's fortified with calcium and vitamins, which is a plus for daily nutrition. However, the presence of gellan gum means the texture might feel a little watery or thin for those who prefer a richer, creamier plant milk. It's a solid, everyday staple if you're watching sugar but might leave you wanting more body.
Pros
- - Very low sugar content
- - Fortified with essential vitamins
Cons
- - Texture may feel thin
- - Contains stabilizers
Organic Kids Chocolate Oat Milk
This organic oat milk is designed with little ones in mind, using coconut sugar for a gentle sweetness that feels more natural than refined white sugar. The inclusion of pea protein is a smart move, offering a bit more staying power to help keep kids focused during the school day. I imagine the flavor is a smooth, chocolatey treat without being cloyingly sweet. The trade-off here is the cocoa powder and coconut sugar, which can settle at the bottom. You'll definitely need to give it a good, vigorous shake before pouring to ensure the flavor is consistent from the first sip to the last.
Pros
- - Organic ingredients
- - Added pea protein
Cons
- - Requires vigorous shaking
- - Can be pricier
M&M's Milk Chocolate Share Size
This is a classic candy for a reason, but the label tells a story of pure sugar rush. With 63g of sugar, it's an intense sweetness that hits fast, paired with that signature milky chocolate melt. The texture relies heavily on cornstarch and soy lecithin to create that smooth, melt-in-your-mouth feel. It's a nostalgic treat, perfect for sharing during a movie night. But for daily snacking, that sugar load and the inclusion of artificial flavors make it a less-than-ideal choice for anyone trying to maintain steady energy levels. It's a deliberate treat, not a health-conscious grab.
Pros
- - Classic creamy texture
- - Nostalgic flavor profile
Cons
- - Extremely high sugar
- - Contains artificial flavors
Extra Creamy Almondmilk
The ingredient list here is beautifully short, and the zero sugar content is a standout feature for anyone strictly managing their intake. What truly sets this apart is the high oleic sunflower oil; it's designed to deliver a noticeably richer, velvety mouthfeel that many other unsweetened milks lack. This would be a dream for creating a frothy latte or a creamy smoothie without adding any sugar. The only trade-off is that the richness comes purely from the fat, so it won't add any sweetness to your coffee or cereal. You're getting a luxurious texture, but you'll need to sweeten it yourself if that's what you're after.
Pros
- - Zero sugar
- - Rich, creamy texture
Cons
- - Completely unsweetened
- - Higher in fat
Toffee & Almonds In Milk Chocolate
This bar is a textural experience: the snap of milk chocolate giving way to a chewy, buttery toffee crunch. The sugar content is very high at 50g, which is what creates that intense, addictive sweetness that coats your tongue. The ingredients list confirms this is a dessert item through and through, with organic butter adding a rich, savory depth. It's a fantastic occasional indulgence, perhaps for a weekend treat. The downside is that the sweetness can be overwhelming, and the sticky toffee bits can be a challenge for sensitive teeth. It's a delicious but deliberate departure from a low-sugar, whole-food mindset.
Pros
- - Rich buttery toffee
- - Satisfying crunchy texture
Cons
- - Extremely high sugar
- - Very sweet flavor
The Verdict
FINAL VERDICT: While Fairlife delivers a quick protein punch, its dairy base can be a gut disruptor, especially before bed. Digesting animal protein late at night can be taxing. For a truly holistic approach, we recommend reaching for a carton of Extra Creamy Almondmilk. It's entirely plant-based, free from dairy hormones, and much easier for your system to process. You get a creamy, satisfying texture without the potential for bloating or inflammation. It provides a lighter form of protein and healthy fats that can actually promote satiety and better rest, aligning perfectly with a gentle, gut-friendly evening ritual.
Buying Guide
When choosing a late-night beverage, scan the ingredient list first. Look for minimal, recognizable ingredients. If you opt for a protein shake, consider the source: whey and casein are effective but can be inflammatory for some. Plant proteins like pea or almond are excellent alternatives. Pay attention to added sugars; they can disrupt sleep cycles. For a whole-food option, a small bowl of organic oat milk with berries provides fiber and comfort. Always listen to your body—if a product causes bloating, it's not serving you, no matter the protein count.
FAQ
Q: Is it okay to drink almond milk every night?
For most people, yes. Unsweetened almond milk is low in calories and sugar, making it a fine evening choice. It contains vitamin E and healthy fats. Just ensure you aren't allergic to nuts and pick a brand without excessive gums or fillers if you have a sensitive stomach.
Q: How much protein do I really need at night?
The amount varies by activity level, but 15-25 grams is a common target for muscle repair. However, for simple satiety and sleep support, a smaller amount from a gentle source like almond milk or a bit of nut butter can be just as effective without overloading your digestive system.
Q: Who should be cautious with dairy-based shakes?
Individuals with lactose intolerance, a known dairy sensitivity, or conditions like acne and eczema often see improvements when avoiding dairy. If you experience consistent bloating, congestion, or skin issues after consuming dairy, a plant-based shake is a much safer bet for your evening routine.
Q: What's the best way to store almond milk?
Always keep your almond milk refrigerated and sealed. Once opened, most brands last 7-10 days. The 'Extra Creamy' versions are great for drinking plain as they have a richer mouthfeel that can feel more satisfying than standard versions, helping to curb cravings with less volume.
How We Review & Trust
Our reviews are based on extensive research, ingredient analysis, and real-world feedback. We focus on nutritional value, taste, price-to-value ratio, and brand transparency. We buy products anonymously to ensure unbiased results.
Navigating late-night hunger is about listening to your body's need for rest, not stimulation. While a Fairlife shake offers protein, its dairy foundation can work against a peaceful night. Choosing a gentle, plant-based option like almond milk supports your gut, reduces bloating, and helps you wake up feeling refreshed, not heavy. It's a small swap that honors your body's natural rhythm.
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, CakeID earns from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like

Plain Yogurt on Keto Isnt Just About Carbs
January 13, 2026
The 2 a.m. Pretzel Crunch
January 13, 2026
The 10 p.m. Crunch That Might Help
January 13, 2026
Late Night Crunch Without The Spike
January 13, 2026
Clear Skin Yogurt Reality Check
January 13, 2026




