That Fluffy Cake Mix Has a Secret

Key Takeaways
- The Deluxe Cake Mix needs a doctoring-up to taste truly homemade.
- The Sweet Hawaiian Rolls are airy but lack that satisfying, buttery chew.
- The Pacific Whiting fillets are a surprisingly solid, simple dinner choice.
I remember when a cake mix was just flour, sugar, and a little bit of hope. You'd add your own eggs and butter, and the whole house would smell like a real celebration. It was a simple joy, a way to bring everyone to the table without a fuss.
Now, the boxes feel lighter and the ingredient lists read like a science experiment. I picked up a few from the Great Value line, curious if that same simple joy was still there. I was looking for that comforting taste, but I found some surprising differences in texture and flavor.
So I put them to the test in my own kitchen. From a sweet roll that felt a little too light to a fish fillet that cooked up beautifully, I wanted to see which ones were worth your hard-earned money and which ones you might want to skip altogether.
Sugar Analysis

Comparison of sugar content per serving (Lower is better).
The Redditor's Verdict
"What the community is actually saying..."
The general consensus seems to be that these are a mixed bag. Shoppers appreciate the budget-friendly prices for stocking the pantry. However, many note a noticeable difference in texture and richness compared to name brands. The cake mix often gets a 'just okay' rating, while the frozen fish and crackers are frequently called out as decent, reliable options for everyday meals.

Great Value Sweet Hawaiian Rolls
The best overall choice based on taste, ingredients, and value.
In-Depth Reviews
Great Value Sweet Hawaiian Rolls
Reading the label on these Sweet Hawaiian Rolls, you're looking at a pretty standard enriched flour dough with just 3g of sugar per 100g. That's surprisingly low for something that tastes so soft and vaguely sweet. They bake up pillowy and golden, smelling like a proper bakery treat. I tucked these into my kid's lunchbox as a special surprise, and they were a hit. The trade-off is that they don't have a super complex flavor; they're simple, and if you're used to a crustier bread, the texture might feel a bit too soft and uniform. But for the price, they're a decent pantry staple.
Pros
- - Soft, pillowy texture
- - Low sugar content for a sweet roll
- - Bakes up golden and quick
Cons
- - Flavor is quite simple
- - Texture lacks a satisfying crust
Great Value Deluxe Moist White Cake Mix
This Deluxe Moist White Cake Mix has a sugar content of 41g per 100g, which is quite high, so it's definitely a treat. The ingredients list is what you'd expect for a convenient box mix. The promise of 'moist' is likely delivered by that sugar and the enriched flour base. For a child's birthday party, this is the kind of easy win that saves you an hour in the kitchen. The texture comes out soft, almost fudgy if you don't overbake. The honest trade-off is that the sweetness can be overwhelming if you're sensitive to it, and the bleached flour is something some people prefer to avoid. It's a classic for a reason, though.
Pros
- - Very easy to prepare
- - Produces a consistently moist crumb
- - Affordable party solution
Cons
- - Very high sugar content
- - Uses bleached flour
Great Value Whole Wheat Egg Noodles, 12 oz
The ingredient label for these Whole Wheat Egg Noodles is beautifully simple: just whole durum wheat flour and egg yolks. With only 3g of sugar per 100g, it's a solid base for a nourishing meal. They have a robust, nutty flavor and a firm bite that holds up wonderfully in a rich broth or a casserole. I made a big pot of chicken soup for a chilly evening, and these noodles made it feel incredibly comforting. The trade-off is that the whole wheat texture is denser and less 'slippery' than traditional white noodles, which might not appeal to everyone, especially picky kids. But for a wholesome, satisfying dish, they're fantastic.
Pros
- - Simple, clean ingredient list
- - Excellent firm and chewy texture
- - Low sugar and whole grain
Cons
- - Denser texture than white pasta
- - May not appeal to picky eaters
Great value, buttery crackers with whole wheat
These buttery crackers with whole wheat have a surprising 12g of sugar per 100g, which adds a subtle sweetness to the savory, toasted flavor from the soybean oil and enriched flour. The texture is crisp and shatters nicely, perfect for topping with cheese or just eating by the handful. I packed these in my gym bag for a quick carb-and-fat boost after a workout, and they hit the spot. The main trade-off is that they can be a bit oily, leaving a sheen on your fingers. Also, the soybean oil might be a dealbreaker for some households. They're a solid, affordable cracker, though.
Pros
- - Satisfyingly crisp and buttery
- - Contains whole grain wheat
- - Great for pairing with toppings
Cons
- - Can be quite oily
- - Contains soybean oil
Great Value Frozen Wild Caught Pacific Whiting Skin-On Fillets, 2 lb
The label for these Frozen Wild Caught Pacific Whiting Fillets is as clean as it gets: just fish. With 0g of sugar, it's pure protein. The fillets are mild and flaky, cooking up quickly from frozen. For a busy weeknight, this is a lifesaver; I pan-seared some for a fast fish taco night, and the skin got wonderfully crispy. The trade-off is that whiting is a very delicate fish, and the texture can be a bit soft or fall apart easily if you're not careful. It's also very mild, so it really needs seasoning or a good sauce to shine. But for clean, convenient fish, it's hard to beat.
Pros
- - Incredibly clean ingredient list
- - Wild-caught and no added sugar
- - Cooks quickly from frozen
Cons
- - Texture can be very delicate
- - Very mild flavor needs seasoning
The Verdict
FINAL VERDICT: The Great Value Frozen Wild Caught Pacific Whiting Skin-On Fillets are the real star of this bunch. They cook up flaky and moist, with the skin getting nicely crisp in a hot pan. The flavor is clean and mild, just like a good fish should be, without any of that 'fishy' smell. It's a simple, honest piece of food that feels like a real meal. You can bake it, pan-sear it, or even air fry it for a quick dinner. It's a reliable choice that doesn't feel like a compromise, reminding me of the simple, quality ingredients we used to get from the market.
Buying Guide
When you're at the store, look at the ingredient list and the weight. For the frozen fish, make sure the fillets are individually frozen and not one giant block of ice; that's a sign of better quality handling. For the cake mix, check the box date for freshness. The crackers should feel crisp, not soft. Price is important, but sometimes spending a few cents more gets you a product that tastes much closer to what you remember from scratch.
FAQ
Q: How can I tell if the frozen fish is fresh?
Look for packages that are frozen solid with no signs of freezer burn or large ice crystals. The fillets should be white and opaque, not yellowing. Trust your nose when you open it; it should smell like the ocean, not have a strong, unpleasant odor.
Q: Are these rolls good for a big family dinner?
They are very soft and sweet, which kids often enjoy. If you're looking for a more substantial, bread-y roll to soak up gravy, you might find these a bit too light. They bake quickly, so keep an eye on them to avoid over-browning.
Q: What's a good way to store the crackers?
The key is to keep them away from air and moisture. Once you open the sleeve, transfer any leftovers to a sealed glass jar or a sturdy plastic container with a good lid. This will keep them crisp for much longer than just folding the bag over.
Q: Can I use the cake mix for something other than a cake?
Absolutely. Many people use it as a shortcut for cupcakes or even to make cookie bars by adding an extra egg and some oil. It can be a versatile base if you think of it more as a pantry staple than just a one-use box.
How We Review & Trust
Our reviews are based on extensive research, ingredient analysis, and real-world feedback. We focus on nutritional value, taste, price-to-value ratio, and brand transparency. We buy products anonymously to ensure unbiased results.
In the end, cooking is about nourishment and connection, not just convenience. While some of these products might need a little extra touch of butter or a sprinkle of your own herbs to truly shine, others are a pleasant surprise. It's about finding those simple, honest ingredients that help you put a good meal on the table for the people you love.
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, CakeID earns from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like

Plain Yogurt on Keto Isnt Just About Carbs
January 13, 2026
The 2 a.m. Pretzel Crunch
January 13, 2026
The 10 p.m. Crunch That Might Help
January 13, 2026
Late Night Crunch Without The Spike
January 13, 2026
Clear Skin Yogurt Reality Check
January 13, 2026




