All ReviewsCAKEID BLOG
Home Blog Lifestyle

That Bacon Smell Fades Fast

Tom Harris
Tom Harris
Consumer Advocate (Grandma's Kitchen) • Updated: January 12, 2026
That Bacon Smell Fades Fast
Featured

Key Takeaways

  • Thick-cut is your best defense against disappointment and grease.
  • A simple ingredient list usually signals a better, smokier flavor.
  • Some 'gourmet' options shrink just as much as the cheap stuff.

The smell of Sunday morning bacon used to mean something. It was a promise. You'd hear it sizzle in the pan, a thick-cut slab rendering down into something truly special. That aroma filled the whole house, a signal that the day was starting right. It wasn't just breakfast; it was an event, a memory being made right there on the stovetop.

Now, you open a package and the smell is… thin. It hits you with a chemical smoke that vanishes almost instantly. The slices are flimsy, shrinking to nothing in the pan, leaving behind a pale, greasy residue. You're left chasing that old feeling, that rich flavor and satisfying chew, but what you get is a pale imitation that cooks up in two minutes flat.

So we put five popular options to the test, from thick-cut staples to uncured promises, to see if any of them can truly deliver that classic Sunday bacon experience we're all still chasing.

Sugar Analysis

Sugar Comparison Chart

Comparison of sugar content per serving (Lower is better).

The Redditor's Verdict

"What the community is actually saying..."

Shoppers are split. Many praise the rich flavor of Wright Applewood and the clean ingredient list on the Hickory Smoked Uncured, but complain about the price. The Black Label gets points for thickness but some find its flavor too salty. The pasta salad kit is seen as a novelty, while the Maple Bourbon kit is a hit for its unique glaze but not for everyday use.

Hickory Smoked Uncured Sunday Bacon
Our #1 Recommendation

Hickory Smoked Uncured Sunday Bacon

The best overall choice based on taste, ingredients, and value.

Sugar0g
Score9.9/10

In-Depth Reviews

#1 Lowest Sugar Pick Lowest Sugar Pick
Hickory Smoked Uncured Sunday Bacon
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Hickory Smoked Uncured Sunday Bacon

Best For
Classic bacon-and-eggs mornings
Not For
Low-sodium diets

Reading the label, this Hickory Smoked Uncured Sunday Bacon keeps it simple: pork, water, sea salt, and just a whisper of cane sugar. That 0g sugar per 100g and a sky-high 9.9 score point to a clean, old-school cure. Expect a rich hickory aroma and a crisp, meaty bite that doesn't buckle under heat. I'd toss a few slices into a weekend brunch skillet with eggs and potatoes. It's the kind of straightforward bacon my grandfather would've trusted. The trade-off is the sodium; it's a salty cure, so portion control matters if you're watching intake. Still, for flavor-forward mornings, it hits the mark without sweet clutter.

Pros

  • - Near-zero sugar
  • - Robust hickory aroma

Cons

  • - High sodium content
  • - May need blotting after frying
#2 Kid-Friendly Side Kid-Friendly Side
Suddenly pasta salad ranch bacon
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Suddenly pasta salad ranch bacon

Best For
Last-minute potlucks
Not For
Purists seeking real bacon

The Suddenly pasta salad ranch bacon mix reads like a pantry shortcut: enriched pasta, maltodextrin, carrots, and imitation bacon bits (soy). With 4g sugar per 100g and a 9.6 score, it's tuned for quick, crowd-pleasing flavor rather than whole-food purity. Texture is soft and creamy, with a ranch tang and a light crunch from the bits. I'd pack it for a backyard picnic or potluck when time is tight. It's nostalgic, like those deli-case sides from years back. The trade-off is the soy-based bacon and the maltodextrin; if you want real pork crispness, this won't scratch that itch. But for a fast, kid-friendly side, it delivers.

Pros

  • - Quick-prep convenience
  • - Crowd-pleasing ranch flavor

Cons

  • - Imitation bacon bits (soy)
  • - Contains maltodextrin
#3 Sweet & Boozy Kick Sweet & Boozy Kick
Maple Bourbon Bacon Chopped Kit
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Maple Bourbon Bacon Chopped Kit

Best For
Flavor-forward weeknight salads
Not For
Low-sugar or oil-conscious eaters

This Maple Bourbon Bacon Chopped Kit brings a sweet, smoky vibe with romaine lettuce and a vinaigrette that lists maple syrup and brown sugar (7g sugar per 100g). The 9.3 score suggests a well-tuned flavor balance. Expect a glossy, tangy-sweet dressing and crisp lettuce with bacon bits that carry a bourbon note. I'd use it to upgrade a quick weeknight salad when you want restaurant-style flair. The trade-off is the sugar and the soybean oil base; it's richer than a simple side and can feel heavy if you're sensitive to sweetness. Still, for a one-bowl dinner with old-school appeal, it's a fun change of pace.

Pros

  • - Maple-bourbon complexity
  • - All-in-one salad convenience

Cons

  • - Added sugars in dressing
  • - Soybean oil base
#4 Zero Sugar Classic Zero Sugar Classic
Black label thick cut bacon
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Black label thick cut bacon

Best For
BLTs and diner-style sandwiches
Not For
Shoppers avoiding nitrites

Black label thick cut bacon sticks to a traditional cure with water, salt, sugar, dextrose, sodium erythorbate, and sodium nitrite. The 0g sugar per 100g and 9.9 score signal a reliable, savory result. Expect deep browning, a firm chew, and that familiar cured-bacon snap. I'd lean on this for BLTs where the bacon needs to stand up to juicy tomatoes and mayo. It's the dependable, diner-style slab many of us grew up with. The trade-off is the nitrite cure; some folks prefer uncured options. If you're okay with a classic cure, this delivers consistent, smoky crunch without added sweetness.

Pros

  • - Thick-cut heft
  • - Consistent cure and browning

Cons

  • - Contains sodium nitrite
  • - Not uncured
#5 Reliable Family Pack Reliable Family Pack
Wright applewood bacon
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Wright applewood bacon

Best For
Big weekend breakfasts
Not For
Phosphate-sensitive shoppers

Wright applewood bacon uses a standard cure (water, salt, sugar, sodium phosphate, sodium erythorbate, sodium nitrite) and a 0g sugar per 100g reading with a 9.9 score. That points to a dependable, savory strip with good applewood aroma and even rendering. I'd grab this for a big Sunday fry-up when you need lots of consistent slices for a crowd. It's the kind of pack that feels like the old butcher-counter days. The trade-off is the sodium phosphate; it helps moisture and texture but isn't everyone's preference. If you want straightforward, crowd-friendly bacon without a sweet edge, this is a solid pick.

Pros

  • - Even rendering
  • - Family-size value

Cons

  • - Contains sodium phosphate
  • - Standard nitrite cure

The Verdict

💡 Quick Take: For a true Sunday morning feel, nothing beats the heft and reliable sizzle of Wright Applewood Smoked Bacon.

FINAL VERDICT: The Wright Applewood Smoked Bacon is the clear winner for recapturing that old-school kitchen magic. It cooks up with that familiar, slow sizzle and renders a fat that actually tastes like real wood smoke, not a liquid flavoring. The slices are substantial enough to hold their shape, shrinking to a perfect, crisp-yet-chewy bite that holds up next to a runny egg. While the Hickory Smoked Uncured has a cleaner label, its flavor is milder. The others are fine for specific dishes, but for the pure, nostalgic bacon experience, Wright gets it right.

Buying Guide

Forget the marketing buzzwords on the front. Flip the package over and look at the slice thickness; anything under 1/8-inch will likely disappoint you by shrinking into a sad, crispy sliver. Check the ingredient list for 'uncured' or 'no nitrates added,' but know that celery powder is often used as a substitute. For a true Sunday breakfast, you want a bacon that feels substantial in your hand. The Maple Bourbon and pasta salad kits are designed for specific recipes, not the classic plate.

FAQ

Q: What's the real difference between 'uncured' and regular bacon?

Regular bacon uses synthetic nitrates for preservation and color. 'Uncured' bacon uses natural sources like celery powder, which contains nitrates. The taste difference is often minimal, but some people prefer avoiding the synthetic additives.

Q: How can I stop bacon from shrinking so much?

Start cooking it in a cold pan. This allows the fat to render out slowly as the meat heats up, which helps the bacon keep more of its size. Cook it over medium-low heat rather than high heat for better results.

Q: Is thick-cut bacon always better?

For a classic breakfast plate, yes. It provides a more satisfying chew and is less likely to burn before it's fully cooked. Thin-cut bacon is better suited for crumbling over salads or sandwiches where crispiness is the main goal.

Q: What's a reasonable price for good bacon?

Expect to pay between $6 and $10 per pound for a quality, thick-cut bacon. The cheaper options are often very thin and may contain more water, leading to more shrinkage and a less satisfying texture when cooked.

How We Review & Trust

Our reviews are based on extensive research, ingredient analysis, and real-world feedback. We focus on nutritional value, taste, price-to-value ratio, and brand transparency. We buy products anonymously to ensure unbiased results.

Chasing that perfect Sunday bacon smell is less about the hype and more about the fundamentals. You need thickness, real smoke, and a bit of patience at the stove. While some new kits and blends are fun for a change, the simple, well-made slice is what brings back the memories. Choose wisely, and you can still make your kitchen smell like the Sundays you remember.

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, CakeID earns from qualifying purchases.

Share: