The 3 PM Fry-Up

This ketchup has a surprisingly sweet profile, likely due to the tapioca syrup and added sugar listed on the label. The texture might be a bit thicker than usual, given the concentrate base. It's a standard condiment option, but the nutritional score of 3.1 suggests it's not the most balanced choice out there. It could work for a casual BBQ, but you might want to watch the portion size. The sodium is reduced, which is a plus, but the sugar content is something to keep an eye on if you're tracking intake. It's a familiar taste, just with a different nutritional footprint.

With a stellar 9.8 score, this ketchup is clearly a standout for those prioritizing health metrics. The sugar content is exceptionally low at just 2g per 100g, which is impressive for a condiment that still uses tapioca syrup and sugar. The ingredient list is straightforward, relying on tomato concentrate and vinegar for that classic tang. It might taste slightly less sweet than traditional brands, which could be a pro or con depending on your palate. It's a fantastic option to keep on hand for low-carb meals or for kids' lunches without the sugar spike. The texture should be smooth and pourable.

This is your quintessential, pantry-staple ketchup. The ingredient list features high fructose corn syrup, which gives it that familiar, bold sweetness and a very smooth, almost glossy texture. The 7.8 score is respectable, placing it in the middle of the pack. It's the reliable choice for burgers and fries that tastes exactly like what you'd expect from a diner. The tang from the distilled vinegar cuts through the sweetness nicely. If you're not avoiding HFCS and just want a dependable bottle for general use, this fits the bill perfectly. It's a crowd-pleaser for a reason.

This ketchup strikes a great balance with a solid 8.3 score and a 17g sugar content. The use of vine-ripened tomatoes in the concentrate suggests a potentially richer, more authentic tomato base. It also contains both high fructose corn syrup and corn syrup, so the sweetness is definitely there, but it's likely backed by a deeper flavor. The texture should be thick and satisfying. I could see this being a go-to for a late-night grilled cheese, where that robust tomato flavor really shines. It's a step up from the most basic options without venturing into specialty territory.

For the organic shopper, this ketchup delivers a clean label with organic tomato concentrate and organic sugar. The 8.3 score matches its non-organic twin, but the ingredient quality is the main draw here. You can expect a straightforward, slightly less processed flavor profile—sweet but not overwhelmingly so, with a classic ketchup tang. It's the kind of bottle you'd feel good about squeezing onto your kid's plate. The texture is likely thick and rich. It's a reliable organic option that doesn't sacrifice the classic taste, making it an easy swap in any kitchen.