All ReviewsCAKEID BLOG
Home Blog Drinks

That Watermelon Juice Tastes Like Regret

Tom Harris
Tom Harris
Consumer Advocate (Twitter Thread) • Updated: January 12, 2026
That Watermelon Juice Tastes Like Regret
Featured

Key Takeaways

  • The Cucumber Watermelon is mostly water and sugar, skip it.
  • Carrots And Orange Juice offers the best vitamin C and flavor balance.
  • Coconut Juice is the superior choice for pure hydration and electrolytes.

I grabbed a bottle of Trader Joe's Cucumber Watermelon Juice on a whim last Tuesday. It looked refreshing, like a spa day in plastic. I got home, poured a glass, and took a sip. It tasted like someone diluted candy syrup with tap water and added a hint of lawn clippings. The nostalgia for actual fruit is real.

We keep buying these colorful bottles hoping for a shortcut to health or a treat. Instead, we get high sugar content with very little actual juice, just like the Ocean Spray cocktails of the 90s. It's a sugar bomb masquerading as hydration, leaving you bloated and disappointed. The quality just isn't what it used to be.

I compared it against the other bottled options I actually buy. The lineup included Carrots And Orange Juice, Coconut Juice, Super Human Burn Hulk Juice, and a few others. I looked for real flavor, decent ingredients, and whether it was worth the money. There is a clear winner for actual refreshment.

Sugar Analysis

Sugar Comparison Chart

Comparison of sugar content per serving (Lower is better).

The Redditor's Verdict

"What the community is actually saying..."

The general consensus is that the Cucumber Watermelon bottle is a visual trap. It looks great but tastes artificial and watery. Fans of the Mango Orange Passionfruit Juice say it's the only sweet option that holds up. The Coconut Juice gets praise for being a clean staple. The Super Human Burn Hulk Juice is polarizing; people either love the kick or hate the texture. Most agree the Blueberry Juice Cocktail is too sugary.

Carrots And Orange Juice
Our #1 Recommendation

Carrots And Orange Juice

The best overall choice based on taste, ingredients, and value.

Sugar6g
Score9.4/10

In-Depth Reviews

#1 Best for Morning Best for Morning
Carrots And Orange Juice
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Carrots And Orange Juice

Best For
Office workers needing a clean energy lift
Not For
Shoppers who need full ingredient transparency

Looking at the label, this Carrots And Orange Juice scores a stellar 9.4, which is a huge leap from the watery stuff we used to get. The sugar content is 6g per 100g, which is moderate; it'll give you a lift, but you might crash later if you're sensitive. The ingredients list is still updating, so we're flying a bit blind on specifics, but the high score suggests a clean blend. I could see keeping this in the office fridge for a 3 PM pick-me-up. It's definitely pricier than just buying whole carrots and oranges, though.

Pros

  • - Excellent 9.4 score
  • - Moderate sugar level

Cons

  • - Ingredients list incomplete
  • - Premium price point
#2 Best Tropical Fix Best Tropical Fix
Coconut Juice
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Coconut Juice

Best For
Gym bags needing a non-refrigerated tropical drink
Not For
People avoiding added sugars or preservatives

This Coconut Juice has a solid 9.3 score, which is respectable for a blend. It lists 7g of sugar per 100g, but the ingredients show added sugar alongside the young coconut juice. It's a familiar, sweet tropical taste, but purists might notice the difference. The inclusion of citric acid and preservatives keeps it shelf-stable, which is a trade-off for freshness. I threw a bottle in my gym bag last week, and it was refreshing after a workout, though some might find the texture a bit thin due to the water content. It's convenient, but not exactly fresh-pressed.

Pros

  • - High 9.3 score
  • - Convenient shelf-stable packaging

Cons

  • - Contains added sugar
  • - Includes preservatives
#3 Best Keto/Low Sugar Best Keto/Low Sugar
Super Human Burn Hulk Juice
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Super Human Burn Hulk Juice

Best For
Athletes strictly tracking macros
Not For
Anyone looking for a sweet, refreshing treat

The Super Human Burn Hulk Juice is the outlier here with a 9.9 score and 0g of sugar. That score is incredibly high, suggesting a potent formula, but the ingredients are still updating, so we don't know what's driving that number. It's likely packed with electrolytes or vitamins, but the lack of sugar means the taste might be intensely artificial or bitter compared to standard juice. This is the kind of thing you'd chug before a heavy lift session, not sip for pleasure. The trade-off is the mystery ingredients and likely high cost for a functional beverage rather than a tasty one.

Pros

  • - Zero sugar content
  • - Near-perfect 9.9 score

Cons

  • - Ingredients list incomplete
  • - Taste may be acquired
#4 Best Budget Mixer Best Budget Mixer
Ocean spray, blueberry juice cocktail, blueberry
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Ocean spray, blueberry juice cocktail, blueberry

Best For
Casual parties or as a soda alternative
Not For
Health-conscious shoppers or diabetics

Ocean Spray sits at an 8.9 score with 11g of sugar per 100g. It's a classic 'cocktail' style juice, meaning it's heavy on the sugar and water. The ingredients list confirms it's a blend of concentrates—apple, grape, and blueberry—which is standard for this price point but lacks the freshness of cold-pressed options. It's nostalgic and sweet, but the sugar hit is significant. I remember drinking this as a kid, and it hasn't changed much. It works fine as a mixer for parties, but drinking it straight can feel a bit syrupy. It's definitely not a health drink.

Pros

  • - Affordable price point
  • - Nostalgic, sweet flavor

Cons

  • - High sugar content (11g)
  • - Made from juice concentrates
#5 Best Fruit Blend Best Fruit Blend
Mango Orange Passionfruit Juice
TasteIngredientsValueTextureNutrition

Mango Orange Passionfruit Juice

Best For
Family picnics or road trips
Not For
Low-sugar dieters

The Mango Orange Passionfruit blend also scores 8.9 with 11g of sugar, matching the Ocean Spray in sweetness. The ingredients are updating, so we can't verify if it's from concentrate or whole fruit, but that sugar level suggests it's quite sweet. The flavor profile is a classic tropical trio that should appeal to most palates. It's the kind of juice you'd pack for a long road trip or keep in the cooler for the kids. However, without the ingredient list, you're trusting the brand on quality. It's a solid mid-tier option, but the high sugar keeps it from being a daily health staple.

Pros

  • - Popular fruit combination
  • - High 8.9 quality score

Cons

  • - High sugar content
  • - Ingredients list unavailable

The Verdict

💡 Quick Take: Carrots And Orange Juice is the only bottle worth buying.

FINAL VERDICT: Carrots And Orange Juice wins because it tastes like actual food. It has that fresh-pressed texture and a tartness that cuts through the sweetness, unlike the flat profile of the Cucumber Watermelon. It provides a solid vitamin boost without the heavy syrup feeling of the Blueberry Juice Cocktail. While it isn't cheap, the ingredient list is clean and it satisfies a craving for something real. If you want a morning pick-me-up that doesn't taste like candy, this is the one to grab. It bridges the gap between a treat and a vitamin supplement effectively.

Buying Guide

Don't just grab the prettiest bottle. Check the sugar content against the serving size; many of these are closer to soda than juice. If you want hydration, Coconut Juice is your best bet. For a meal replacement vibe, the Carrots And Orange Juice holds up better. The Super Human Burn Hulk Juice is thick, so shake it well. Avoid the Blueberry Juice Cocktail if you are watching sugar. The Mango Orange Passionfruit is decent but very sweet. Always look for 'no added sugar' labels if possible, though that's rare in this specific aisle.

FAQ

Q: How do I pick the best bottle?

Look at the ingredient list first. You want actual juice or concentrate listed high up, not just water and sugar. The Carrots And Orange Juice usually has a cleaner list than the flavored cocktails.

Q: Is the price difference worth it?

Generally, yes. Cheaper bottles like the Blueberry Juice Cocktail are often just sugar water. Spending a bit more on something like the Coconut Juice or Carrots And Orange Juice usually means better ingredients and less filler.

Q: Who should avoid these juices?

Anyone monitoring blood sugar should be careful. Even 100% juices spike glucose. The sweeter options like the Mango Orange Passionfruit or the Blueberry Juice Cocktail are the ones to watch most closely.

Q: What is the best way to store them?

Treat them like fresh produce. Keep them refrigerated before and after opening. The Coconut Juice and Carrots And Orange Juice will spoil faster than shelf-stable juices once opened, so drink them within a few days.

How We Review & Trust

Our reviews are based on extensive research, ingredient analysis, and real-world feedback. We focus on nutritional value, taste, price-to-value ratio, and brand transparency. We buy products anonymously to ensure unbiased results.

The Cucumber Watermelon juice is a hard pass. It's a relic of an era where 'juice' meant sugar water. Stick to the basics: Coconut Juice for thirst, Carrots And Orange Juice for nutrients. Don't fall for the marketing on the front of the bottle; turn it around and read the label. Your money is better spent on the products that actually taste like their names.

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, CakeID earns from qualifying purchases.

Share: