CakeID LogoCakeID
Back to Home

Butter Substitute Roundup

We analyzed 2 products to help you choose the healthiest & safest options.

Finding the perfect Butter Substitute shouldn't feel like a guessing game. At CakeID, we take food transparency seriously. We have analyzed over 2 products in this category, breaking down every ingredient list to uncover hidden additives, excessive sugar levels, and potential allergens.

Whether you are searching for strictly Vegan options, Gluten-Free snacks, or simply want to avoid high-processed foods, our algorithm ranks products based on a comprehensive Health Score. Below is our definitive ranking of the safest and healthiest Butter Substitute you can buy in 2026, sorted by their ingredient purity.

Editor's Quick Picks

🏆 Best Overall

Unsalted Butter Sticks

"Highest Score (100/100)."

Detailed Reviews

Calories
571
Sugar
0g
Unknown

Unsalted Butter Sticks

Ingredients: EXPELLER-PRESSED ORGANIC OIL BLEND (COCONUT, HI-OLEIC SUNFLOWER, SUSTAINABLE ETHICAL PALM FRUIT), WATER, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, ORGANIC NATURAL FLAVOR, TOCOPHEROLS (PLANT-BASED PRESERVATIVE), ORGANIC ANNATTO EXTRACT (COLOR)

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score
  • ● Sugar Free

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
714
Sugar
0g
Country Crock

Country Crock Homestyle Salted Butter

Ingredients: BLEND OF PLANT-BASED OILS (PALM FRUIT, PALM KERNEL AND CANOLA OIL), WATER, SALT, PEA PROTEIN, GLUCOSE, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, CITRIC ACID, NATURAL FLAVORS, BETA CAROTENE (COLOR)

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score
  • ● Sugar Free

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis

Frequently Asked Questions

Are products in the Butter Substitute category always vegan?+
Not necessarily. We analyzed over 2 products in the Butter Substitute category on CakeID. While some are plant-based, many contain hidden animal ingredients like milk powder, whey, or gelatin. Always check the "Is Vegan" status on our product pages.
How does CakeID rank the best Butter Substitute?+
We rank Butter Substitute based on their nutritional value, ingredient cleanliness (fewer additives), and vegan compatibility. Products with lower sugar and simpler ingredients rank higher.
Can I find low-calorie Butter Substitute here?+
Yes! Our list highlights the nutritional details of each product. Look for the "Calories" badge on the product cards above to find low-calorie options.