Back to Home

Chocolate Butter Cup Roundup

We analyzed 63 products to help you choose the healthiest & safest options.

Finding the perfect Chocolate Butter Cup shouldn't feel like a guessing game. At CakeID, we take food transparency seriously. We have analyzed over 63 products in this category, breaking down every ingredient list to uncover hidden additives, excessive sugar levels, and potential allergens.

Whether you are searching for strictly Vegan options, Gluten-Free snacks, or simply want to avoid high-processed foods, our algorithm ranks products based on a comprehensive Health Score. Below is our definitive ranking of the safest and healthiest Chocolate Butter Cup you can buy in 2026, sorted by their ingredient purity.

Editor's Quick Picks

Detailed Reviews

Calories
195
Sugar
20g
Turkey Hill

Chocolate peanut butter cup ice cream

Ingredients: Milk, cream sugar, corn syrup, peanut butter swirl, (peanuts, soybean oil, sugar, salt), nonfat milk, whey, cocoa processed with alkali, cellulose gel, cellulose gum, mono & diglycerides, carrageenan.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Corn Syrup
View Full Analysis
Calories
198
Sugar
6g
Rite Aid Corporation

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Ingredients: Cream, skim milk, water, maltodextrin, xylitol, whey protein concentrate, mono & diglycerides, cellulose gum, guar gum, sucralose, carrageenan, chocolate swirl [maltitol syrup, water, cocoa (processed with alkali), modified corn starch, glucono delta lact

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
500
Protein
11g
ChocZero

Peanut Butter Cups - White Chocolate Style

Ingredients: Cocoa butter, whole milk powder, Non-GMO Resistant Dextrin, sunflower lecithin, monk fruit extract, madagascar bourbon vanilla beans, roasted peanuts, peanut flour, sea salt, monk fruit extract, xanthan gum, guar gum, natural caramel flavor.

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
600
Sugar
20g
Evolved

Dark Chocolate Classic Coconut Butter Cups

Ingredients: ORGANIC COCONUT BUTTER, ORGANIC CACAO, ORGANIC COCONUT SUGAR, ORGANIC CACAO BUTTER, HIMALAYAN SEA SALT.

The Good

  • ● Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
538
Protein
15g
Reese's

Reese’s Peanut Butter Lovers

Ingredients: PEANUTS, MILK CHOCOLATE (SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, CHOCOLATE, SKIM MILK, MILK FAT, LACTOSE, LECITHIN (SOY), PGPR), SUGAR, PARTIALLY DEFATTED PEANUTS, DEXTROSE, HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL (PALM KERNEL OIL, SOYBEAN OIL), CORN SYRUP SOLIDS, SALT, PALM KERNEL OIL, LECITHIN (SOY), VANILLIN (ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR), TBHQ, CITRIC ACID.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Corn Syrup
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
257
Sugar
29g
Talenti, Unilever

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Gelato

Ingredients: _Milk_, Sugar, _Peanuts_, Cream, _Egg_ And Egg Yolk, Dextrose, _Coconut_ Oil, Chocolate, Cocoa (Processed With Alkali), Cocoa Butter, Skim Milk, Salt, Carob Bean Gum, _Soy_ Lecithin, Natural Flavor, Cocoa, Vanilla Extract

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
494
Protein
14g
choc Zero

Peanut Butter Cups - Dark Chocolate

Ingredients: Dark Chocolate (unsweetened chocolate, cocoa butter, Non-GMO Resistant Dextrin, sunflower lecithin, monk fruit extract, madagascar bourbon vanilla beans, roasted peanuts, peanut flour, sea salt, monk fruit extract, xanthan gum, guar gum.

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score
  • ● Sugar Free

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
494
Protein
14g
ChocZero

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: Milk chocolate confection (chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, whole milk powder, Non-GMO Resistant Dextrin), sunflower lecithin, monk fruit extract, madagascar bourbon vanilla beans, roasted peanuts, peanut flour, sea salt, monk fruit extract, xanthan gum, guar gum, natural caramel flavor.

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
590
Protein
10g
Reese's

Organic Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: ORGANIC MILK CHOCOLATE (ORGANIC SUGAR, ORGANIC COCOA BUTTER, ORGANIC MILK, ORGANIC CHOCOLATE), ORGANIC PEANUTS, ORGANIC SUGAR, ORGANIC DEXTROSE, ORGANIC COCOA BUTTER, SEA SALT, ORGANIC ROSEMARY EXTRACT.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
310
Sugar
24g
The Fresh Market

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup with Chopped Peanuts

Ingredients: CHOCOLATE (SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, CHOCOLATE LIQUOR, WHOLE MILK POWDER, LACTOSE, MILKFAT, SOY LECITHIN, VANILLA), PEANUT BUTTER (PEANUTS, PALM OIL), CRUSHED PEANUTS, SUGAR, BUTTER, SALT. CONTAINS: MILK, SOY AND PEANUTS. MAY CONTAIN TREE NUTS (ALMONDS, PECANS).

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
383
Protein
11g
Jonesbar

Peanut butter have

Ingredients: ORGANIC DATES ORGANIC PEANUTS ORGANIC CHIA SEEDS HIMALAYAN PINK SEA SALT Contains: Peanuts. *Handcrafted in a top secret facility tha processes peanuts and other nuts. Rea foods may contain pit or nutshell piece Handmade by Jonesbar Wall Township, NJ 07753 USA Certified Organic By WFCF

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
533
Sugar
33g
Unknown

Dark chocolate almond butter cups

Ingredients: NIGREDIENTS - Dark Chocolate (Chocolate Liquort, Cane Sugart, Cocoa Buttert, Organic Blue Agave Inulin,. Sunflower Lecithin, Vanilla Almonds, Organic Cane Sugart, Organic Palm Oil**. Organic Blue Agave Inulin, Organic Coconut Flour. Sea Salt. Sumflern Lecithin

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
545
Sugar
46g
Reese's

THiNS White Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: SUGAR, VEGETABLE OIL (PALM OIL, SHEA OIL, SUNFLOWER OIL, PALM KERNEL OIL, SAFFLOWER OIL), PEANUTS, SKIM MILK, CORN SYRUP SOLIDS, LACTOSE (MILK), DEXTROSE, COCOA BUTTER 2%, HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL (PALM KERNEL OIL, PALM OIL), SALT, LECITHIN (SOY), CORN STARCH, VANILLIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, TBHQ, CITRIC ACID, PGPR.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Corn Syrup
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
568
Sugar
41g
Justin's

Organic Dark Chocolate Crispy Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: ORGANIC DARK CHOCOLATE (ORGANIC EVAPORATED CANE SUGAR, ORGANIC CACAO BEANS, ORGANIC COCOA BUTTER", ORGANIC SOYA LECITHIN [EMULSIFIER]). ORGANIC PEANUT BUTTER (ORGANIC GROUND PEANUTS), ORGANIC CANE SUGAR, ORGANIC QUINOA. ORGANIC PEANUT FLOUR, ORGANIC PALM OIL, SEA SALT, ORGANIC SUNFLOWER LECITHIN

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
512
Sugar
56g
Reese's

Milk chocolate thins peanut butter cups

Ingredients: Milk chocolate [sugar; cocoa butter; chocolate; skim milk; milk fat; lactose; lecithin (soy); pgpr]; peanuts; sugar; dextrose; contains 2% or less of: cocoa butter; hydrogenated vegetable oil [palm kernel oil; palm oil]; salt; palm kernel oil; cornstarch; tbhq and citric acid, to maintain freshness.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
467
Sugar
37g
Chips Ahoy!

Chewy Chips Ahoy! Milk Chocolate Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Cookies/Galletas

Ingredients: Unbleached enriched flour (wheat flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate {vitamin b1}, riboflavin {vitamin b2}, folic acid), high fructose corn syrup, palm oil, reese's peanut butter baking cup (milk chocolate {sugar, cocoa butter, milk, chocolate, soy lecithin, artificial flavor}, peanut butter chips {partially defatted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated palm kernel and soybean oil, corn syrup solids, dextrose, reduced protein whey, palm kernel oil, salt, artificial flavor, soy lecithin}, palm kernel oil), sugar, semisweet chocolate chips (sugar, chocolate, cocoa butter, dextrose, milk, soy lecithin), reese's peanut butter flavored chips (partially defatted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated palm kernel and soybean oil, corn syrup solids, dextrose, reduced protein whey, palm kernel oil, salt, artificial flavor, soy lecithin), cornstarch, dextrose, baking soda, salt, reese's peanut butter cup pieces (milk chocolate {sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate, nonfat milk, milkfat, lactose, soy lecithin, polyglycerol polyricinoleate - emulsifier}, peanuts, sugar, dextrose, salt, tbhq, citric acid), artificial flavor.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains High Fructose Corn Syrup
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
488
Protein
14g
Hail Merry

Chocolate Almond Butter Cups

Ingredients: Organic maple syrup, almond butter, almond flour, dark cocoa, organic virgin coconut oil, sea salt.

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score
  • ● Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
253
Sugar
21g
Dreyer's

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Ingredients: Skim milk, cream, sugar, peanut butter cups (sugar, peanut butter [peanuts, salt], coconut oil, skim milk, whole milk, cocoa processed with alkali, soy lecithin, natural flavor), peanut butter swirl (peanuts, peanut oil, sugar, salt), corn syrup, cocoa processed with alkali (dutched cocoa), whey, guar gum, carob bean gum, natural flavor.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Corn Syrup
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
579
Protein
13g
Theo

Chocolate organic dark chocolate peanut butter cups

Ingredients: COCOA BEANS*+, SUGAR*+, PEANUT BUTTER (ROASTED PEANUTS)*, COCOA BUTTER*+, POWDERED SUGAR (SUGAR, NON-GMO CORNSTARCH)*+, PEANUT FLOUR (ROASTED PEANUTS)*, SALT, ROSEMARY EXTRACT (VEGETABLE OIL, ROSEMARY EXTRACT)*[caret], GROUND VANILLA BEAN*+.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
575
Sugar
40g
Justine’s

White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: Organic white chocolate (organic sugar, organic cocoa butter*, organic whole milk powder, organic soy lecithin, organic vanilla), organic peanuts, organic powdered evaporated cane sugar, organic palm fruit oil**, organic peanut flour, organic cocoa butter, organic vanilla flavor, sea salt, organic soy lecithin.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
516
Sugar
52g
Reese's

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, Peanut Butter

Ingredients: Milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate, nonfat milk, milk fat, lactose, soy lecithin, pgpr, emulsifier), peanuts, sugar, dextrose, salt, tbhq (preservative),

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
625
Sugar
42g
Justin's

Organic Milk Chocolate Mini Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: Organic milk chocolate (organic evaporated cane sugar, organic cocoa butter*, organic whole milk powder, organic chocolate liquor*, organic soy lecithin, organic vanilla), organic peanuts, organic powdered evaporated cane sugar, organic peanut flour, organic palm fruit oil**, organic vanilla flavor, sea salt, organic soy lecithin.

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
0
Sugar
0g
Unreal

Dark chocolate almond butter cup

Ingredients: Dark Chocolate (Chocolate Liquor, Cane Sugar, Cocoa Butter, Vanilla), Almonds, Organic Cane Sugar, Organic Palm Oil, Organic Blue Agave Inulin, Organic Coconut Flour, Sea Salt, Sunflower Lecithin.

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score
  • ● Sugar Free

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
575
Sugar
38g
Seth Ellis Chocolatier, Sun Cups

Rice Syrup Chocolate Sunflower Butter Cups

Ingredients: Rice chocolate (sugar*, cocoa butter*, unsweetened chocolate*, rice syrup powder), sunflower seeds, powdered sugar (evaporated cane juice*, tapioca starch), cocoa butter*, sea salt

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
205
Sugar
21g
Turkey Hill

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Ingredients: MILK, SUGAR, PEANUT BUTTER SWIRL (PEANUTS, SOYBEAN OIL, SUGAR, SALT), CORN SYRUP, COCOA POWDER PROCESSED WITH ALKALI, WHEY, NONFAT MILK, CREAM, POLYDEXTROSE, MONO&DIGLYCERIDES, CELLULOSE GUM, GUAR GUM, CARRAGEENAN

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● Contains Corn Syrup
  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
467
Sugar
0g
Lily's

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: UNSWEETENED CHOCOLATE, ERYTHRITOL CHICORY ROOT FIBER, VEGETABLE OIL (PALM KERNEL OIL, COCONUT OIL, PALM OIL), PEANUTS, PEANUT FLOUR, COCOA BUTTER, SALT, LECITHIN (SUNFLOWER), STEVIA EXTRACT, VANILLA EXTRACT.

The Good

  • ● Excellent Health Score
  • ● Sugar Free

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
571
Sugar
33g
Free2b,Sun Cups

Dark Chocolate Sunflower Butter Cups

Ingredients: dark chocolate (unsweetened chocolate*, sugar*, cocoa butter*), sunflower seeds, powdered sugar (evaporated cane juice*, tapioca starch), cocoa butter*, sea salt

The Good

  • ● Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • ● High Sugar Content
View Full Analysis
Calories
575
Sugar
11g
Trader Joe's

Dark chocolate sunflower seed butter cups

Ingredients: Dark chocolate, cane sugar, sunflower seeds, organic powdered sugar, tapioca starch, cocoa butter, salt

The Good

  • ● Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • ● Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
180
Sugar
1g
Lily's

Twin Pack Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: DARK CHOCOLATE (UNSWEETENED CHOCOLATE, ERYTHRITOL, CHICORY ROOT FIBER, COCOA BUTTER, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, VANILLA EXTRACT, STEVIA EXTRACT), PEANUT BUTTER (PEANUTS, PALM KERNEL OIL, ERYTHRITOL, PEANUT FLOUR, CHICORY ROOT FIBER, COCONUT OIL, PALM OIL SALT, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, STEVIA EXTRACT).

The Good

  • ● Low Sugar

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
484
Sugar
3g
Lily's

Milk Chocolate Style Peanut Butter Cups

Ingredients: ERYTHRITOL, UNSWEETENED CHOCOLATE, SOLUBLE CORN FIBER, COCOA BUTTER, VEGETABLE OIL (PALM KERNEL OIL, COCONUT OIL, PALM OIL), PEANUTS, CHICORY ROOT FIBER, PEANUT FLOUR, MILK, MILK FAT, SALT, LECITHIN (SUNFLOWER), STEVIA EXTRACT, VANILLA EXTRACT.

The Good

  • ● Low Sugar

The Bad

  • ● Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis

Frequently Asked Questions

Are products in the Chocolate Butter Cup category always vegan?+
Not necessarily. We analyzed over 63 products in the Chocolate Butter Cup category on CakeID. While some are plant-based, many contain hidden animal ingredients like milk powder, whey, or gelatin. Always check the "Is Vegan" status on our product pages.
How does CakeID rank the best Chocolate Butter Cup?+
We rank Chocolate Butter Cup based on their nutritional value, ingredient cleanliness (fewer additives), and vegan compatibility. Products with lower sugar and simpler ingredients rank higher.
Can I find low-calorie Chocolate Butter Cup here?+
Yes! Our list highlights the nutritional details of each product. Look for the "Calories" badge on the product cards above to find low-calorie options.
PreviousPage 1 of 3Next