Extract Roundup
We analyzed 92 products to help you choose the healthiest & safest options.
Finding the perfect Extract shouldn't feel like a guessing game. At CakeID, we take food transparency seriously. We have analyzed over 92 products in this category, breaking down every ingredient list to uncover hidden additives, excessive sugar levels, and potential allergens.
Whether you are searching for strictly Vegan options, Gluten-Free snacks, or simply want to avoid high-processed foods, our algorithm ranks products based on a comprehensive Health Score. Below is our definitive ranking of the safest and healthiest Extract you can buy in 2026, sorted by their ingredient purity.
Editor's Quick Picks
Detailed Reviews

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Dark Chocolate With Stevia Extract
Ingredients: COCOA MASS, LACTITOL, INULIN, COCOA BUTTER, EMULSIFIER (SUNFLOWER LECITHIN), VANILLA EXTRACT, SWEETENER (STEVIOL GLYCOSIDES).
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Low Sugar
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Organic Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: WATER, ORGANIC ALCOHOL, ORGANIC VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Madagascar Pure Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: ORGANIC MADAGASCAR VANILLA BEANS EXTRACTIVES IN WATER,, ORGANIC ALCOHOL.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Pure Madagascar Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: ORGANIC VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES, IN WATER, ORGANIC ALCOHOL.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Turmeric 1000mg Plus Black Pepper Extract
Ingredients: Turmeric (Curcuma longa) (root), Turmeric Extract (Curcuma longa) (root) (Standardized to contain 95% Curcuminoids), BioPerineยฎ Black Pepper Extract (Piper nigrum) (fruit), Gelatin, Vegetable Stearic Acid
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Peruvian Coffee with Extracts of Functional Mushrooms
Ingredients: COFFEE, CHAGA MUSHROOM EXTRACT, LION'S MANE MUSHROOM EXTRACT, MAITAKE MUSHROOM EXTRACT, CORDYCEPS MUSHROOM EXTRACT
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Imitation Vanilla Flavor
Ingredients: WATER, SUGAR, CARAMEL COLOR, PROPYLENE GLYCOL, ETHYL VANILLIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ High Sugar Content

SmartWater+ Tranquility Ashwaganda Tangerine Extract
Ingredients: vapor distilled water, tangerine extract, calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, ashwaganda extract, potassium bicarbonate.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Simply organic pure Madagascar vanilla extract
Ingredients: organic vanilla bean extractives, water, organic alcohol.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Pure Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: vanilla bean extractives in water, ethyl alcohol.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: WATER, ORGANIC ALCOHOL, ORGANIC VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Liquid Stevia Extract Sweetener
Ingredients: WATER, ERYTHRITOL, STEVIA EXTRACT, NATURAL FLAVORS, MALIC ACID, SODIUM BENZOATE (PRESERVATIVE), POTASSIUM SORBATE (PRESERVATIVE).
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Contains Sodium Benzoate

Organic Premium Quality Pure Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: Certified organic alcohol (35% minimum), certified organic vanilla bean extractions, and water.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

All Natural Handcrafted Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla with Pure Vanilla Extract with Other Natural Flavors
Ingredients: Water, sugar, glycerin, vanilla extract (water, alcohol, extractive of vanilla beans), alcohol, natural flavors, fruit juice (color).
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Pineapple Chunks In Water Sweetened With Stevia Extract
Ingredients: pineapple, water, natural flavors, citric acid, stevia extract
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Vanilla Flavor, Non-Alcoholic Organic
Ingredients: ORGANIC GLYCERIN, WATER, ORGANIC VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES. PRODUCED IN A FACILITY THAT PROCESSES TREE NUTS, MILK, EGGS, WHEAT, SOY AND SESAME
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Contains Tree Nuts

Liquid Monk Fruit Extract Sweetener
Ingredients: Water, Monk Fruit Extract, Natural Citrus Flavors
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Vanilla Extract, Organic
Ingredients: WATER, ORGANIC ALCOHOL, ORGANIC VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES. PRODUCED IN A FACILITY THAT PROCESSES TREE NUTS, MILK, EGGS, WHEAT, SOY AND SESAME
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Contains Tree Nuts

Organic Extract Powder Zero-Calorie Sweetener
Ingredients: organic stevia leaf extract.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed

Organic Vanilla Extract
Ingredients: WATER, ORGANIC\LCOHOL, ORGANIC, VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES.
The Good
- โ Excellent Health Score
- โ Sugar Free
- โ Clean Ingredients
The Bad
- โ Ultra Processed
