Back to Home

Plant Butter Roundup

We analyzed 542 products to help you choose the healthiest & safest options.

Finding the perfect Plant Butter shouldn't feel like a guessing game. At CakeID, we take food transparency seriously. We have analyzed over 542 products in this category, breaking down every ingredient list to uncover hidden additives, excessive sugar levels, and potential allergens.

Whether you are searching for strictly Vegan options, Gluten-Free snacks, or simply want to avoid high-processed foods, our algorithm ranks products based on a comprehensive Health Score. Below is our definitive ranking of the safest and healthiest Plant Butter you can buy in 2026, sorted by their ingredient purity.

Editor's Quick Picks

Detailed Reviews

Calories
576
Protein
21g
Planters,Kraft

Planters, crunchy peanut butter, banana granola crunch, banana granola crunch

Ingredients: Roasted peanuts, sugar, dried bananas (bananas, sugar), granola (rice flakes [brown rice flour, rice bran, salt, distilled monoglycerides], evaporated cane juice, crisp rice [rice flour, brown rice flour, canola oil], dried banana, canola oil, brown rice syrup, natural flavor, salt), hydrogenated vegetable oil blend (rapeseed, cottonseed, soybean oils), salt, natural flavor.

The Good

  • Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
22g
Sprouts Farmers Market

Creamy No Stir Peanut Butter

Ingredients: ROASTED PEANUTS, CANE SUGAR, PALM OIL (SUSTAINABLY SOURCED), SALT, CONTAINS: PEANUTS, MAY CONTAIN: TREE NUTS (ALMOND, CASHEW)

The Good

  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
25g
Thrive Market

Peanut Butter

Ingredients: DRY ROASTED PEANUTS, SALT, PEANUT

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
604
Protein
18g
Maisie Jane's

Organic Cashew Butter

Ingredients: organic dry roasted _cashews_

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
625
Protein
22g
Natural Way

Original Almond Butter made with olive oil

Ingredients: dry roasted almonds, olive oil, salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
625
Protein
19g
H-E-B

Crunchy Almond Butter

Ingredients: dry roasted almonds, palm oil stearin, sea salt.

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
0
Sugar
0g
Teddie

peanut butter smooth unsalted

Ingredients: peanuts

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Sugar Free
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
500
Protein
22g
The Pistachio Factory

Pistachio Butter

Ingredients: roasted _pistachios_, sea salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
571
Protein
29g
American Dream

Bundle Up Blondie Almond Butter

Ingredients: ROASTED ALMONDS, WHEY PROTEIN (WHEY PROTEIN ISOLATE, NATURAL FLAVORS, STEVIA), GLUTEN FREE GOLDEN SANDWICH COOKIES (SUGAR, CORNSTARCH, TAPIOCA SYRUP, PALM OIL, PEA STARCH, WHITE RICE FLOUR, POTATO STARCH, TAPIOCA STARCH, CASSAVA FLOUR, PEA PROTEIN, SALT, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, NATURAL FLAVOR, PEA FIBER, EGG, SOY LECITHIN, INULIN, SODIUM BICARBONATE, MODIFIED CELLULOSE, BETA-CAROTENE, XANTHAN GUM, BAKING SODA), WHITE CHOCOLATE CHIPS (SUGAR, PALM OIL, MILK, SOY LECITHIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR), BUTTERSCOTCH CHIPS (SUGAR, PALM OIL, NAT - URAL FLAVORS, ARTIFICIAL FLAVORS, FD&C [YELLOW #6 LAKE, YELLOW #5 LAKE, BLUE #2 LAKE], VANILLIN, SALT, SOY LECITHIN)

The Good

  • Convenient Snack

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
643
Protein
21g
achva

Tahini

Ingredients: tatal fat 20% saturated fat 15% trans fat 0% carbs 2% dietary fiber 4g 15% vitamins D omcg calcium 24smg iron 2mg potassium 122mg

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Sugar Free
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
643
Protein
14g
Crazy Go Nuts

Walnut Butter, Plain with Sea Salt

Ingredients: _WALNUTS_, SEA SALT

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
679
Protein
21g
Soom

Tahini

Ingredients: Sesame seeds

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Sugar Free
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
25g
Unknown

Organic Old Fashioned Peanut Butter

Ingredients: Dry Roasted Organic Peanuts, Sea Salt.

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
190
Sugar
1g
Georgia Grinders

Hazelnut Butter

Ingredients: Roasted Hazelnuts, Sea Salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
562
Protein
19g
Artisana Organics

Raw Cashew Butter

Ingredients: raw organic cashews

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
0
Sugar
0g
Yumbutter

Organic Peanut Butter, Classic Creamy

Ingredients: Almonds, Organic Palm Oil*, Organic Chia Seeds, Organic Hemp Seeds, Organic Coconut Sugar, Organic Goji Berry Powder, Organic Lucuma Powder, Pink Himalayan Salt. tion Contains Almonds and Coconut. Contains trace amounts of Peanuts and Tree Nuts due to processing on shared equipment. *Our palm comes from organic, fair-trade, sustainable farms. See our website for more details. Manufactured By: Tribe 9 Foods, Madison, WI 53716 Carefully produced in a gluten-free facility.

The Good

  • Sugar Free

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
210
Sugar
0g
Sun & Seed

Organic Sunflower Seed Butter 250g

Ingredients: 100% ORGANIC _SUNFLOWER SEEDS_

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Sugar Free
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
220
Sugar
1g
Sun & Seed

Organic Raw Walnut Butter 250g

Ingredients: 100% ORGANIC _WALNUTS_

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
25g
Stater bros markets

Old fashioned peanut butter

Ingredients: Dry roasted peanuts, salt.

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
240
Sugar
1g
Purely Pecans

Nuttin' but Pecans

Ingredients: _Pecans_

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
462
Protein
39g
PB2

Crunchy Powdered Peanut Butter

Ingredients: ROASTED PEANUTS, SUGAR, SALT.

The Good

  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
563
Protein
25g
Simply More

Organic Peanut Butter

Ingredients: ORGANIC PEANUTS, SEA SALT.

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
486
Sugar
5g
ChocZero

White Chocolate Hazelnut Spread

Ingredients: Non-GMO resistant dextrin, vegetable oils and fats (sustainable palm fruit oil, coconut oil, cocoa butter), roasted hazelnut, skim milk powder, sunflower lecithin, monk fruit extract, natural vanilla flavor.

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
25g
Naturally More

Organic Peanut Butter Creamy

Ingredients: Organic Peanuts, Sea Salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
22g
H-E-B

Peanut Butter

Ingredients: PEANUTS, SUGAR, FULLY HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL (RAPESEED, COTTONSEED, AND/OR SOYBEAN OIL), SALT, MOLASSES

The Good

  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
571
Sugar
0g
Shoprite

Plant-based Buttery Spread

Ingredients: expeller-pressed organic oil blend (coconut oil, sustainable ethical palm fruit oil, canola oil, high-oleic sunflower oil, flaxseed oil) water, sea salt, sunflower lecithin, organic natural flavor, tocopherols, organic annatto extract color.

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Sugar Free

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
562
Protein
25g
Shoprite,Bowl & Basket

Natural Peanut Butter (Creamy)

Ingredients: Peanuts, Salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
613
Protein
19g
H-E-B

Creamy Almond Butter

Ingredients: dry roasted almonds, palm oil, sea salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Low Sugar
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Ultra Processed
View Full Analysis
Calories
594
Protein
22g
H-E-B Organics

Crunchy Peanut Butter Spread

Ingredients: organic peanuts, organic palm stearin, organic cane sugar, sea salt

The Good

  • Excellent Health Score
  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis
Calories
563
Protein
22g
Kroger

Creamy Peanut Butter

Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil (rapeseed, cottonseed, and soybean), salt, molasses

The Good

  • Clean Ingredients

The Bad

  • Contains Peanut
View Full Analysis

Frequently Asked Questions

Are products in the Plant Butter category always vegan?+
Not necessarily. We analyzed over 542 products in the Plant Butter category on CakeID. While some are plant-based, many contain hidden animal ingredients like milk powder, whey, or gelatin. Always check the "Is Vegan" status on our product pages.
How does CakeID rank the best Plant Butter?+
We rank Plant Butter based on their nutritional value, ingredient cleanliness (fewer additives), and vegan compatibility. Products with lower sugar and simpler ingredients rank higher.
Can I find low-calorie Plant Butter here?+
Yes! Our list highlights the nutritional details of each product. Look for the "Calories" badge on the product cards above to find low-calorie options.
PreviousPage 1 of 19Next